Skip to main content
  • Home
  • About IHEP
    • About IHEP
    • Message from our President
      • Message from our President
      • Speaking Engagements
      • Opinions & Commentaries
    • History
      • History
      • IHEP Champions of Access and Success
      • Equity First for 25 Years
        • Equity First for 25 Years
        • 25 Years of Research and Action
    • What We Do
      • What We Do
      • Five Facts to Fix
    • Who We Are
      • Who We Are
      • IHEP Staff
      • Experts
      • Board of Directors
    • Partners
      • Partners
      • Funding Partners
      • Networks and Coalitions
    • Working at IHEP
      • Working at IHEP
      • Career Opportunities
    • Contact Us
      • Contact Us
      • IHEP Staff
      • Join Our Mailing List
  • Policy Priorities
    • Policy Priorities
    • Access & Success
    • Affordability & Finance
    • Accountability & Transparency
    • Critical Communities & Institutions
  • Research
    • Research
    • Publications
    • Search Publications
    • Current Initiatives
      • Current Initiatives
      • College Not Prison
      • Film Series: Federal Student Aid History
      • Postsecondary Data Collaborative
      • Degrees When Due
      • Assessing The Impact of Prison-Based Postsecondary Education Programs
    • Previous Initiatives
      • Previous Initiatives
      • Global Initiatives
        • Global Initiatives
        • Global Policy Fellows Program
      • Minority-Serving Institutions-Models of Success Program
      • Summer Academy
        • Summer Academy
        • Participating Institutions
      • Community Partnership for Attainment
        • Community Partnership for Attainment
        • Participating Communities
      • Symposium on Financial Literacy and College Success at Minority-Serving Institutions
        • Symposium on Financial Literacy and College Success at Minority-Serving Institutions
        • Participating Institutions
      • Walmart Minority Student Success Initiative
        • Walmart Minority Student Success Initiative
        • Participating Institutions
      • BEAMS
        • BEAMS
        • Participating Institutions
      • Project Win-Win
      • Redefining Access for the 21st-Century Student
      • Reimagining Aid Design and Delivery
      • Pathways to College Network
  • Press
    • Press
    • News Releases
    • Opinions and Statements
    • Press Clips
  • Events
    • Events
    • IHEP Events
    • Staff Presentations
  • Donate

25 Years of Equity

Twitter Facebook Vimeo

  • Home
  • About IHEP
    • Message from our President
      • Speaking Engagements
      • Opinions & Commentaries
    • History
      • IHEP Champions of Access and Success
      • Equity First for 25 Years
        • 25 Years of Research and Action
    • What We Do
      • Five Facts to Fix
    • Who We Are
      • IHEP Staff
      • Experts
      • Board of Directors
    • Partners
      • Funding Partners
      • Networks and Coalitions
    • Working at IHEP
      • Career Opportunities
    • Contact Us
      • IHEP Staff
      • Join Our Mailing List
  • Policy Priorities
    • Access & Success
    • Affordability & Finance
    • Accountability & Transparency
    • Critical Communities & Institutions
  • Research
    • Publications
    • Search Publications
    • Current Initiatives
      • College Not Prison
      • Film Series: Federal Student Aid History
      • Postsecondary Data Collaborative
      • Degrees When Due
      • Assessing The Impact of Prison-Based Postsecondary Education Programs
    • Previous Initiatives
      • Global Initiatives
        • Global Policy Fellows Program
      • Minority-Serving Institutions-Models of Success Program
      • Summer Academy
        • Participating Institutions
      • Community Partnership for Attainment
        • Participating Communities
      • Symposium on Financial Literacy and College Success at Minority-Serving Institutions
        • Participating Institutions
      • Walmart Minority Student Success Initiative
        • Participating Institutions
      • BEAMS
        • Participating Institutions
      • Project Win-Win
      • Redefining Access for the 21st-Century Student
      • Reimagining Aid Design and Delivery
      • Pathways to College Network
  • Press
    • News Releases
    • Opinions and Statements
    • Press Clips
  • Events
    • IHEP Events
    • Staff Presentations
  • Donate

You are here

Home / Press / News Releases

Accountability Challenges In The U.S. Higher Education System Are Setting Students Up For A Tough Time In The Global Economy

Study Finds Europe’s “Bologna Process” Gaining Momentum to Become the Dominant Global Model of Higher Education by 2020, Calls for Serious Reforms in American Degree Standards, Credits, and Diplomas

.

Washington, D.C., July 28, 2008—While access to postsecondary education has increased in the United States despite the rising cost of degree attainment, America now lags behind other countries when it comes to assuring the public of what its degrees mean. The United States’ current “accountability” campaigns offer numbers, not quality indicators. In contrast, 46 European countries that have been working since 1999 on changing the way they conduct higher education focus first on defining each degree in terms of learning outcomes. Our 3,300 colleges, community colleges, and universities have much to learn from their efforts in order to ensure a more secure position for our students in a global economy. This is the principal message of a policy brief released today by the Institute for Higher Education Policy (IHEP).

The report, Learning Accountability from Bologna: a Higher Education Policy Primer, examines the reconstruction of those 46 European higher education systems—known as the “Bologna Process”—in terms of addressing challenges that lie at the core of current debates in the United States about documenting student learning. Written by higher education researcher Clifford Adelman, the study explores the core features of change in Europe that have been created jointly by higher education administrators, faculty, students, and national ministries of education.

“The U.S. higher education system, the world’s most complex, is imperfectly struggling with accountability issues,” said Adelman, “yet the largest restructuring of higher education the world has ever seen has addressed accountability in ways we have not even imagined.” “Bologna is a work in progress, but pieces of it have already been imitated and adapted in Latin America, Africa, and Australia, and it is well on its way to becoming the dominant global paradigm of higher education within the next two decades.”

The Bologna Process at-a-Glance

The Bologna Process is being carried out across 23 major languages from Iceland to Turkey, Portugal to Russia, and affects 4,000 institutions and 16 million students, a size comparable to the U.S. system of higher education. The core features of Bologna’s “harmonization” include:

  • Every degree is publicly defined so that everyone knows what it means in terms of the demonstration of knowledge; the application of knowledge; fluency in the use of information; breadth, depth, and effectiveness of communication; and degree of autonomy gained for subsequent learning. These definitions are performance criteria, and to earn a degree, a student must “demonstrate” defined levels of mastery along each of these lines of learning.
  • Everyone can recite the difference in performance criteria for an associate’s degree, a bachelor’s degree, and a master’s degree, and the public language of these criteria clearly ratchets up the performance bar at each level.
  • Credits are based on a common standard of student workload, not faculty contact hours, and (in a growing list of countries) each course is assigned a level of challenge so that the combination of workload and level guarantees transfer of credits.
  • Every student who earns a degree receives, as a supplement to the diploma (and in addition to a transcript), an official documented summary of the setting, nature, purpose, and requirements of the degree and major program—and a shorthand descriptive warrantee of what the student did to earn the degree.

Reconstructive Suggestions for Change in the United States

Reflecting on Bologna Process changes, the policy brief provides recommendations on how to address accountability challenges facing U.S. postsecondary education. If implemented, these initiatives would provide public reference points for student learning and performance. These suggestions all follow a student-centered story line, and include:

  • Developing detailed and public degree qualification frameworks for state higher education systems and in students’ major fields;
  • Revising the terms of the American credit system by adding a rating of academic challenge for each course’s credits; and
  • Developing a distinctive U.S. version of a diploma supplement that summarizes individual student achievements in ways that a transcript does not do.

Learning Accountability from Bologna, is the second publication in a five-part IHEP series under its Measuring Global Performance Initiative. The first study, a longer and more detailed essay, The Bologna Club: What U.S. Higher Education Can Learn from a Decade of European Reconstruction, was released in May and covers access and accountability issues, and was also written by Adelman. Both publications, along with a Web-based information resource center that includes more than 500 documents in 22 Bologna-inspired topical categories, are available on IHEP's Web site.

Launched in 2007, the Measuring Global Performance Initiative aims to create a new understanding of the rapidly changing global context for learning and credentialing in higher education, and the potential impact of these changes in the United States. The initiative covers not only the Bologna Process and its implications, but also the challenge of constructing more enlightening international comparative indicators of participation, pathways, and attainment in higher education than are currently available.

The initiative is supported by Lumina Foundation for Education, an Indianapolis-based private foundation striving to help people achieve their potential by expanding access to and success in education beyond high school.

About the Institute for Higher Education Policy

The Institute for Higher Education Policy (IHEP) is an independent, nonprofit organization that is dedicated to increasing access and success in postsecondary education around the world. Established in 1993, the Washington, D.C.-based organization uses unique research and innovative programs to inform key decision makers who shape public policy and support economic and social development. IHEP’s web site, www.ihep.org, features an expansive collection of higher education information available free of charge and provides access to some of the most respected professionals in the fields of public policy and research.

Media Contact

Kathryn Gimborys
202-861-8223 x 131

News Archive

  • 2018 (4)
  • 2017 (7)
  • 2016 (12)
  • 2015 (15)
  • 2014 (8)
  • 2013 (10)
  • 2012 (14)
  • 2011 (14)
  • 2010 (21)
  • 2009 (13)
  • 2008 (14)
  • 2007 (16)
  • 2006 (11)
  • 2005 (10)
  • 2004 (9)
  • 2003 (6)
  • 2002 (6)
  • 2001 (5)
  • 2000 (7)
  • 1999 (3)
  • 1998 (8)
  • 1997 (4)

Press

  • News Releases
  • Opinions and Statements
  • Press Clips

© Institute for Higher Education Policy 1993-2015.
1825 K Street, N.W., Suite 720 Washington, DC 20006
(202) 861-8223 TELEPHONE (202) 861-9307 FAX
institute@ihep.org  |  Join Our Mailing List | Read Our Privacy Policy

© Institute for Higher Education Policy
1993-2014.
1825 K Street, N.W., Suite 720 
Washington, DC 20006
(202) 861-8223 TELEPHONE
(202) 861-9307 FAX
institute@ihep.org
Join Our Mailing List